Guide
Doctor dues and cash shifts: closing a polyclinic month without disputes
Disputes with doctors start when their percentage is calculated on a different base from the one agreed (billed or collected, before or after lab and material costs, and what happens to amounts the insurer rejected), and when cash shifts are closed without a recorded count and a check. The fix is to write the rule down, calculate dues from the same records that hold the cash and the claims, and close every shift on its own day.
Last reviewed:
In this guide
This guide is for the owner, general manager and finance manager of a polyclinic. It gives no legal opinion on doctors' contracts; it explains the mechanics that make the number the same for everyone. To see how dues and cash work from the clinic's own record, see finance for clinics.
What are the common doctor pay models?
In private polyclinics you usually see one of these, or a mix:
- Fixed salary. The simplest to calculate. It is paid through payroll and follows the normal procedures for employee wages, including the Ministry of Human Resources and Social Development's Wage Protection Program, which monitors wage payments to workers in private-sector establishments.
- Salary plus a percentage above a threshold. The doctor earns a percentage of revenue above an agreed monthly amount.
- Straight percentage of revenue. Common with visiting doctors and some consultants.
- Percentage after direct costs. In dentistry, for example, lab fees, implants and materials are deducted before the percentage is applied.
- Fixed fee per procedure. For some operations or sessions.
Whatever the model, the contract or its annex should answer five questions: which revenue does the percentage apply to? Is the base billed or collected? Which costs come off first? What happens to insurer rejections, discounts and refunds? When are dues paid? The wording of the contract itself belongs with a legal adviser.
Why do disputes start at the gap between billed and collected?
Billed is the value of the services the doctor delivered. Collected is what actually reached the drawer or the bank. The gap between them has known causes:
- The insurer's share is not paid yet, or part of it was rejected when the claim went through NPHIES.
- A discount the group gave the patient, or a contractual discount to the insurer.
- A treatment plan paid in instalments.
- A refund after a cancelled session or procedure.
An illustrative example with made-up numbers: a doctor on 30%. In the month they delivered SAR 100,000 of services, of which 60,000 were for insured patients. Insurers paid 45,000 by month-end and rejected 3,000; self-paying patients paid 38,000 of 40,000. On a billed basis the doctor is due SAR 30,000. On a collected basis, SAR 24,900 (30% of 83,000). The rest depends on later collections and on the rule for rejections.
The dispute does not come from the method chosen. It comes from the doctor calculating one way and the accountant another, or from the accountant only seeing rejected and collected amounts per doctor by hand. So give each doctor a monthly statement that shows, for every visit: billed, collected, rejected, deducted and the percentage. If they object, the objection is to a specific line, not to a total.
How is a cash shift opened and closed?
A cash shift is the period during which one person is responsible for one drawer or one collection point. The steps:
- Open. The cashier records the opening float and signs for it.
- Collect. Every payment is recorded in the shift with the right method: cash, card (mada and credit cards) or transfer. A card payment recorded as cash is the most common cause of differences.
- Refunds and payouts from the drawer. Not one riyal leaves the drawer without a document and an approval.
- Close. The cashier counts the cash and enters the count, which shows the difference against the expected amount. They print the settlement report from the card terminal and match it to the shift's card total.
- Verify. An accountant or supervisor reviews the shift, records the reason for any difference, then the cash is deposited and posted.
Two rules prevent most problems: no new shift for a cashier until the previous one is closed, and no shift closed without the name of the person who verified it.
On cancellations and refunds: an issued invoice is never deleted or edited, and a refund goes through a credit note that references the original invoice, as set out in ZATCA's E-Invoicing Detailed Guideline. If cash leaves the drawer without a note, the revenue stays on the books and the drawer shows a shortage.
How do you treat deposits, advances and doctor loans?
A patient's deposit or prepayment for a treatment plan or session package is not the doctor's revenue yet. It is recorded as a balance in the patient's favour and becomes revenue, and so a doctor due, when the service is delivered and the prepayment is used. If the percentage is calculated on the day the deposit arrives, the doctor is paid for work not yet done, and it gets messy if the patient cancels and asks for a refund.
Advances to doctors are booked to the doctor's account and deducted from their dues as agreed, and the balance appears on the same monthly statement so it is neither forgotten nor deducted twice.
What is on the month-end checklist?
Last working day
- Every shift of the month closed and verified, none left open.
- Every bank deposit matched to cash shifts.
- Card-terminal reports matched to card collections.
First three days of the next month
- Insurer payments received are allocated to their claims, and rejections classified.
- Unused prepayments reviewed, none of them counted as revenue before the service.
- Lab and material costs recorded against the right doctor and case.
Before dues are paid
- A statement per doctor showing visits, billed, collected, rejected, discounts and advances.
- A written window for objections, each against a specific line.
- Finance manager approval, then payment and posting.
To see why this list is hard when the clinic system and the accounting program are separate, read what gets lost between the clinic system and the accounting program. To cut rejections at the source, read the most common claim rejection reasons.
How Nixpend helps
In Nixpend the clinic, insurance, cash shifts, doctor dues, inventory, purchasing, HR and payroll, and accounting share one record. Doctor dues are therefore calculated from the same visits, collections and rejections that sit in the books, and shifts close with a recorded count and check. When you move to Nixpend, our own team moves your patients, balances, doctor dues and history from the old system. See finance in Nixpend or book a demo.
FAQ
Is the doctor's percentage calculated on billed or collected revenue?
Both are used. What matters is that the contract sets the base, says what happens to rejections, discounts and refunds, and that the figure comes from the same records as the books.
What causes most cash-drawer differences?
A card payment recorded as cash, a refund paid from the drawer without a document, and a shift left open for two days.
When does a patient's deposit become a doctor due?
When the service is delivered and the deposit is used, not on the day it is received.
How do I reduce doctors' objections?
With a detailed monthly statement per visit and a written window for objecting to a specific line.
Sources
- Ministry of Human Resources and Social Development, Wage Protection Program
- ZATCA, E-Invoicing Detailed Guideline, version 2, May 2023
See Nixpend on a day like yours
A 30-minute walk through the platform, on a scenario close to your day: from the booking to the claim and the journal entry.